It's hard to beat this tape for performance.  We've been using it for many years for packing boxes and never had a problem.  You do have to press it down to make sure it's going to stick well if you're going to leave packages outdoors or in your garage for the postal service to pick up, but that's true with most of this type of tape.  We've used other brands that were so frustrating to use because they were so thin and hard to manage.  We always come back to this tape instead.