This review is about the DVD version of PULSE. I had high hopes for this DVD. To me this is not Pink Floyd. This is David Gilmour's band on DVD playing Pink Floyd covers and the circumstances of the time led Gilmour to stamp this as Pink Floyd. On video quality I give this a 2/5, and audio 1/5. The audio is truly annoying and poor on the DVD version. I appreciate the genius that Roger Waters brought to Pink Floyd, and the virtuosity of David Gilmour and Richard Wright, but you can't call yourself Pink Floyd without Roger Waters. My two cents.