I've ordered this a couple of times and purchased from the local pet store and it was great.  The last case ordered through Amazon (ick) was the sloppy kind mentioned by a few other reviewers and my 10 month old puppy won't eat it. - tried 8 different cans from the case and they are all the same. I've have now been making my own chopped fresh chicken and mashed sweet potato to mix in with the dried Wellness puppy food.  She devours every bit.  Sorry Wellness I normally really like your product but this is really bad form when you buy a whole case that cannot be used :(