My cat absolutely would not eat more then one bite of the Mixed Grill and eventually pretty much stopped eating them all together. preferring to eat the dry kibble all together. the only way I can get her to eat and finish what is left is to mix it with the flakey bits that have more gravy. The pate is just to pasty and doesn't go down as well as the gravy variety and on more then one occasion would get caught in her throat causing her to gag and vomit. If left for any period of time it would dry very quickly making it nearly impossible for her to get off the saucer should she try to come back to and I usually had to throw more away then she could eat and I only feed her 1/4 can in the morning and at night with dry Friskies and water available to her 24/7. Left overs don't store in the fridge well either and must be chopped up as once refrigerated it clumps together were as the flakes of meat in gravy do not  I can also find it cheaper at the local Kroger's and with a bigger variety of flavors unlike being forced to buy 3 specific flavors and one of which she won't eat at all. The flakes in gravy don't smell as strong as this stuff either. And I care enough about my pet that if I wouldn't eat anything that smells as bad going in as it does coming out then I sure wouldn't eat it and there is no way I'd expect her to do the same. I know she sounds like a finicky cat and maybe so but sometimes the smell of this stuff in the morning would make me gag as well.