My geriatric cat LOVED the senior formula. The only reason I stopped the subscription was she had kidney disease and was prescribed Hill's k/d. It was the clear winner of an extensive grain-free taste test that included Weruva, Spot's Stew, Blue Buffalo, and others I forget. My only complaint is many of the cans had dents. This did not affect the quality or her willingness to eat it, but is obviously not a good thing.