Only one of our 6 indoor and chubby cats even made an attempt at eating this! I was shocked because their diet is usually dry kibble, and if they get canned food it is usually received as a treat and gobbled up. But the other five just sniffed at it and walked away! I must say the food was rather chunky and I tried mashing it up a bit for them, and it didn't have a very appealing smell. Now I am left with about 20 tins of this stuff and only one cat that will eat it. Must say I am very disappointed and I wish I knew what it is that is turning the others off this food :(