I got these the other day for our dog. We have a pittie/ boxer mix, about 45 pounds. He loves his treats. I love that fact that the ingredients in these treats offer a pretty small list of items, and are better items than most treats out there. Pitties hav e alot of skin problems from allergies apparently, so when we get generic or cheap treats with bad items in them, he breaks out in rashes. I'm happy to say that these pass the test and he's just as happy today as yesterday and had no reaction.