Not sure how to review this.  I have bought other flavors and it's just fine.  I did not realize this had beef livers and pork plasma in the ingredients.  Skipped right over it, I guess. Absolutely do not recall reading it in the ingredients list.  My one cat is allergic to beef and the other just won't eat this food.  It's my opinion a poultry product should just have poultry ingredients in it. That's why the two stars, that and because my cats just don't like it and I'm stuck with a whole case of it. Twenty-four bucks down the drain.  I can't shop at brick and mortar stores, have to order online.  It would be better to be able to just try a couple cans at a time instead of having to buy a whole case just to try it out. Try to feed them healthy foods, get punished in the pocketbook.