This is far from the consistency I was expecting.  Unlike the same product which was purchased at my local national pet store, my puppy is simply not interested in eating  this soupy stuff.  The product purchased from my local national pet store chain had a much firmer consistency which my puppy liked very much when mixed with the Wellness dry food. I am very disappointed with this purchase.  Too bad I have to throw out the rest of the case and this brand is not cheap!