3/2/2014 Updated Review - I've purchased this food both from Amazon and PetSmart and my puppies always loved it.  It was a thick consistency with bits of carrots.  Now, the food has changed to a repulsive mess with black flakes of something that looks like fish scales.  They hate it and I think it is disgusting.  I first received this nasty mess in every can in 3 out of the 4 cases I just received from Amazon.  I went to PetSmart to buy more hoping it would be the original consistency and once again, I have a case of nasty food.  I placed another order from Amazon hoping to get the good food they love but if I don't, it will be returned.  There is clearly something very wrong with these cans of food.  It is so different from what they've eaten since they were six weeks old, now 8 months old and there is no other explanation other than Wellness has changed the recipe.  I've inquired with Wellness to find out what is going on.  I plan to switch foods and have purchased canned Blue puppy and hope they will eat it even though it is a sudden change from the food they've always loved.