My dogs liked this food, and the ingredients seems good but the quality control of the product was so bad you didn't know what would be in the can.  It has gone from a firm content to a sticky soft goo, large chunks of what I think was bones (they crumbled not hard but I wouldn't want my dogs to eat them) sometime all around the can was a gel (I called them and they said it was broth that separated from rest of the ingredients) sometimes lots of large sweet potato chunks.  The main complaint was it seldom came out of the can as a whole to cut it into equal parts and it was never the same consistency.