5 stars? Get real. The debut from Eagles is worth highest rating but this album is far from that standard. Yes, there's the song "Hotel California" and I agree that it's one of Eagles' best ever, and probably one of the greatest songs regardless of artists/bands. Apart from "Victim of love" and "Hotel California", the material is quite weak and very uninteresting. "New kid in town" and "Life in the fast lane" are usually considered great among Eagles fans, but I believe they're both pretty [bad]. I suggest you get the three first albums because they display Eagles in their prime. I would give this album only 1 star if it wasn't for the song "Hotel California" (which is indeed a 5 star song).