True there are some faults with this show, but come on folks, this was one great concert. Read the reviews and you will see how many people contradict one another. The only problem I had was Sinead was barely audible when singing "Mother". Members of "The Band" singing the  mother's part was good. Roger in concert 7-13-00 at the Garden sings his  part and has the female vocalists sing the mother's part. I like to hear  good artists doing other people's music. The fact that so many major acts  of that time showed up, shows the respect that Roger Waters gets in the  music industry. I feel that they stayed as true to the music as possible.  His band, The Bleeding Heart Band can play this piece as well as Pink Floyd  did. Rick Difonzo plays his guitar almost exactly like Mr. Gilmour. Mr.  Waters still has some of these great musicians in his band today like  Graham Broad, Andy Fairweather Low and Snowy White. Rent the video and if  you don't like it then you don't know a classic show even if it bites you  on your behind. The Scorpions did an excellent job with "In the  Flesh" both parts and I'm not a Scorpions fan. Van Morrison did a very  soulful version of "Comfortably Numb". The Orchestra was superb,  they probably never preformed in front of such a large audience. Any one  who claims to be a Waters fan or a Pink Floyd fan should enjoy this CD and  the video. I wish this would be released on DVD, then you have the best of  both worlds. Any chance to see Roger Waters in concert no matter what band  he has or music he chooses to perform should jump at the chance. This  concert was an historical event and is a must for any collector of live  shows.