First off, I think everything that could be said about this concert probably already has been, but I haven't read all of the reviews. Here's my two cents...Let me start by saying THIS IS ONE GREAT SHOW!!! Rodger Waters as well as his band are just quite simply - PERFECT! Waters has assembled several(now)legendary guests to help perform The Wall in where else but Berlin.... The album is pretty much performed verbatum. FYI, these guests generally only perform one song and this is generally earlier on in the show before Rodger Waters takes over full-time. I have to admit I was a bit skeptical about even renting this because of some of these guests. I have mulled over this DVD and passed on it many times since discovering it's exsistence a couple years ago. Boy was I wrong. This concert really works overall and just keeps getting better and better while building up to a truly amazing finish!  It's impossible to give it justice with mere words. YOU HAVE TO SEE & HEAR THIS! By now, you guys probably already know who's in this. I'm not a big Cindy Laupner fan. She actually does a fine job on this and does so in her own classic Laupner style. It works, somehow..., but it works. And Apparently Rodger was a fan of The Last Waltz, as he invited several members of The Band, as well as some others from that classic concert, to do a couple songs from The Wall album - all in their own unique styles. I'm a big big fan of The Last Waltz and while it's nice to see these guys again, I'd have to say that they are somewhat out of place in this particular venue. They lend a country twang to the song they perform which, in my opinion, is questionable... The most suprising and impressive performance though, would have to be Sinead O'Conner(sp?) singing "Mother" w/ a little help from THE Band. Surprisingly, she may just be the best single guest artist of the entire show. I've always found her to be a bit odd..., but she really hits it on this night. It surprised the you know what out of me! Also, The Scorpians do a great job on all the songs they perform. But beyond the guest appearances, Rodger Walters performs & sings most of the songs himself w/ his band. Let me tell you something. This guy is not missing a beat. Everything he does, is spot on and he recreates the songs much like the actual album. He is definately the master of his domain! He, as well as the show and set are very theatrical & animated all at the same time - just as we've come to expect and then some... I may be wrong, but I don't sense any lip synching going on throughout the show other than "The Trial" song and I'll give them a free pass on that one - you'll see why...