For those who appreciate the modern, "mature" Pink Floyd, Pulse is a masterpiece. For classic Pink Floyd fans, Pulse is very good. Disc one is a thoughtfully-produced set, opening with "Shine On You Crazy Diamond," followed by an early Syd Barrett track. A solid hour of music. The rendition of Dark Side of the Moon on disc two is nearly identical to the original (although that isn't necessarily important), although it has that vibrant, live energy that David Gilmour seems to command. Finally, the encore featuring "Wish You Were Here" and "Comfortably Numb" fantastic. Roger Waters fans will be thoroughly satisfied despite his absence; there's something in it for every Pink Floyd fan and is a must-listen