we have 3 weber grills - this completed the set.  wouldn't use anything but charcoal, and this is better than 3 other small grills we had.  I figured cheaper can't be THAT much worse....boy was I wrong.  If it's not a Smokey Joe by Weber, it's not a grill....it's a cheap piece of metal that might last a summer of camping...if you're lucky.  This is sturdy, easy to put together (if you have patience) and well work a little more than the other cheap-o imitators.  Couldn't be happier