Compared to the Smokey Joe model 10020, it's not gold. I like the ability to lock the lid  while moving it, but unlike the model Weber 10020, it doesn't have air holes at the bottom or a tray to catch ashes at the bottom. After using this grill, it is OK if you leave the lid a little off center to let more air in. It's a toss up between this and the older model. I prefer the holes in the bottom of the grill and the ash catcher which seems to provide better charcoal ignition/burn.