Claire Crater is at a rocking New Year's Eve party but is she celebrating? No, once again she's sitting against a wall writing in her notebook.  Claire is an erotic writer and her characters seriously have a richer love life than Claire ever has.  While searching for her next hero, Claire focuses on a man who is gorgeous and seems slightly familiar.  No, she would remember if she had ever known anyone who looked like him.  Mason Ledbetter along with his best friend, Hunter Morris, went to high school with Claire.  They were the typical class nerds and never had the guts to ask her out even though they wanted to.  While she still looks the same, they have changed--for the better.  Tonight, both Mason and Hunter plan on fulfilling a long-time dream to have Claire between them - not only tonight but forever.  After a night of fireworks, reactions make the two decide to give up Claire.  Too bad they didn't ask her first because she has other ideas.