Not bad for the price.  I found the pigment a little grainy,  but pretty good for beginners or practice. I like the compact set and it has some mixing areas in the lid and center of each disc, but if you're in the field it may be too much to juggle all the parts if you want to look at all the colors at once. I'm happy with the color selection but I would say this is a pallet put together mainly for landscape work. Overall pretty good for the price.