4 stars because there IS a bigger version, which for all intents and purposes in indeed better. there's no "oh it's smaller so trickshots and short throws are easier." No, it's a ring, not a disc, it's made to do one thing, and that is to fly straight and far really well, and be easy to catch. the smaller one does do this pretty well, but the bigger one does it better, plus, you can catch the bigger one with your head which is more entertaining than it sounds