I  remember these in the 80s when they had real cheese that was hard, you would use the stick to cut it into four equal sections (they never gave enough cheese for all the crackers) Now its way worse! the section where the "cheese" is got smaller and it's only HALF FULL of I don't know what, but I certainly wouldn't call it cheese, it's nothing like it used to be, it has the consistancy of soft margarine, gross IMO It tastes chemically and it looks fake too, bleck, I still can't get the gross taste out of my mouth. my dog likes it or it would go in the trash (the cheese part)