I got Mr. Bill for my dogs for Christmas because he was cheap and I just like giving my dogs presents to open on Christmas because they love it so much.  To my surprise both my black labs like Mr. Bill more than the two other expensive quality toys I got them.  Mr. Bill was torn fairly quickly but I still let them play with him when Im watching them and even though the quality isn't that good Id much buy them a cheap toy that they play with and tear up than an expensive durable toy that never gets touched so I gave 5 stars based solely on how much my dogs liked him.