My toy poodle loves this toy! She has the frog as well as the duck.  She played with it so much that she wore the squeaker out.  It is very well made and I will continue buying this for her as a birthday present or a Christmas present.  There are so many toys on the market for dogs that when I find the one special toy my dog will play with over and over I like to have spare toys on hand in case the manufacturer stops making the toy.