I'm glad this toy has no stuffing in it, but for a few dollars more, the Kong Cozie is stuffed firmly and has a squeaker in the middle that lasts and lasts. My puppy has two varieties of the unstuffed Kong animals, one being this frog. They were correct to give you a free extra sqeaker. The toy, without stuffing, is very thin and flimsy, and the squeakers don't last. So far, the toy has not ripped, though, so I think the quality is decent for 5 bucks! But my 8 and 9 dollar Kong Cozies last as well and there is no need for extra squeakers.