Actually I haven't tried any myself (it does smell good) but LUCY LIKES IT!  Lucy is our 15+ year old calico who was always a finicky eater but over the last 3 months has "put herself on a diet" as my wife calls it.  She's tried to feed Lucy firmer food, softer food, meatier food, juicier food & even real baby food.  Each one got sniffed, tested & then ignored.  And what was scaring us was that she was steadily getting thinner & thinner.  Today, this product arrived & Lucy finished her whole plate!  We know it's too soon to judge the new cat food by one meal but we were really getting panicky & it looks like maybe we've found something that'll keep Lucy with us for a few more years.  If she continues to enjoy it, we're going on Subscribe & Save right away.