I was displeased when I saw these treats are cookies because my Toy Chiweenie is not fond of dog cookies.  However, after I broke the cookie into smaller, more manageable sized pieces, she took one quick sniff & immediately began devouring the treat.  SHE LOVES THESE!  And I am very pleased with the limited list of grain-free premium ingredients.  I'm shocked to find a 14 ounce bag of such high quality treats for the low add-on price of only $4.49.  I will definitely be reordering these treats...even if the price increases to three times what I paid for this bag.  And I will also be ordering other types of treats from Natural Balance's LIT line.