I just started giving my puppy the food from this batch of Wellness Just for Puppies- she usually loves this food. The consistency of the food was liquid and she refused to eat it. Opened 2 other cans from this same batch and same consistency! I called Wellpet (Wellness) and after giving serial number on bottom of can , customer rep said this batch was produced in West Coast facility where the product is a loser consistency than product produced in East Coast facility. I wish I knew this before ordering a brand new case of 12 from Amazon this week, Too bad Amazon gets this product from both facilities and doesn't' let consumer know..my puppy knows which consistency she likes-East Coast batch which is firmer and slightly different taste..