We've been feeding Wellness pat mixed with their Core Indoor dry food to our cats for years, first the chicken formula and now the salmon and trout. I am disappointed and completely fed up with the variations in consistency, smell, and--apparently--palatability of this product. I get a case or two that have what I'll call the normal consistency and odor and all three cats eat it well. Then, I get a case or two in a row that are "off": the texture is very firm, almost dry, and the smell is . . . well, let's just say sometimes it's a challenge to stand there and put it in the bowls. When that happens, my cats go from enthusiastically consuming 3 oz. of canned per day plus some dry to barely touching it. And, I don't go swapping it out the moment they reject it; we struggle our way through the entire, 24-can case.