We have 4 dogs. They love these treats. One of my dogs is missing a few teeth from before we adopted him and these are easy for me to break into pieces for him.  Our dogs like these much better than Milk Bone Dog Biscuits. They come in a big cardboard box and are loose inside. Some people complain about a lot of broken bones, so far in 2 boxes we have not had that issue. Maybe 10% or less are broken.