I have my dog on a strict limited ingredient, grain free diet (due to chronic skin rashes and itching) which includes a salmon based dry food, salmon oil, and now these sweet potato/fish treats. She loves them! And they smell delicious even from a human standpoint - no fishy smell. More like jerky. My dog is a medium/large breed (60lbs) and the treats are a good size for her. Not too big or small. I am happy to have found a treat that I feel comfortable feeding her that she really likes. The subscribe and save option is awesome for us. The price is way lower than you can get even at the local pet store, and it is an easy way to make sure we always have them on hand.