All 5 of my cats like this food and flavor.  As well as two strays who get a bit of it mixed with grain-free dry.  I order 2 cases of Wellness per month.  This cat food is about as natural as we can get at a good price in the tall can, compared to needing several short cans for my 5 cats.  I give it 4 stars instead of 5 because Wellness uses carageenan.  I am concerned about giving this ingredient to my cats daily.  Carageenan has shown in lab studies to cause intestinal upset.  While my cats don't have that, I am concerned that daily use could lead to intestinal upset over the long run.  Nearly every company uses carageenan in their wet food.  If there is a company that doesn't, usually they use some other ingredient that is more serious to avoid or it is just too high priced for my budget.  I had a kitty who at 12 years of age developed irritable bowel problems and vomiting that grew worse and worse as she went from 8 to 4 lbs., went on prednisone (nothing natural helped her) and subsequently passed at 13 from malnutrition.  I don't know if this was caused by the carageenan or contributed, but probably not because I tried taking her off this food with no improvement.  I also tried cooking her meat and changed meat sources.  I think the biggest problem for our cats and dogs is the GMO corn that is fed to the animals (chickens, etc) used in pet food.