When having to remove waterproof mascara, I usually fall back on the old standard of baby oil or an equivalent oil. While they may work OK, I don't like the scent in the baby oil, especially when it gets into my eyes, or any oil in my eyes for that matter. So I was really happy to to try this La Roche-Posay waterproof eye makeup remover, since, right away I noticed it did not appear oily, nor was it scented. Also, it was labeled as being safe for "sensitive" eyes (personally, I believe all eyes are sensitive). I've now used this remover several times, with both cotton squares and also tissue, and it works perfectly. I have now permanently settled on the tissue, since I don't like the fact that a cotton square or even a cotton ball can leave small fibers in the eye area and those are not pleasant when they get into the eye, itself.