I used this to remove heavy, black eyeliner, and it worked very well. Black eyeliner is always a mess, and takes some extra doing, but it came right off. I swiped it right across my eye quite a few times, and had no redness, stinging, or irritation. I've also used it as a cleanser. I think it works well, but I just can't get used to the "no water" thing, so I don't mind using this once a day, but I still feel the need to wash with water, too. I do like to use this as a "pick me up" after I've been working in the yard on a hot day. With a quick swipe It cleanses, refreshes, and cools my skin, and I don't have to bother with pulling my hair back to wash my face with water.