I have been using different brands of Micellar Water for about a year. This is hands down the best one I have tried. I have sensitive skin, so the oil prevention one will not work. With the addition of B5 and the mineral rich water to fortify the skin, it is the winner hands-down. I didn't even put make up on today and took a shower before I went to bed. I have not done too much of anything today, so my face should not be too dirty. The cotton pad shows dirt! It may take longer with makeup on, I don't know yet, I will carry some removal wipes just in case when I travel. But then I will follow up with this product to remove any other traces. I do not feel tightness, I just feel clean.