This was my first read of Abigail Reynolds and I heartily enjoyed it.  A few other reviewers say this isn't her finest P&P variation, but I liked it a lot.  Yes, Darcy and Elizabeth both have pretty different personalities compared to their traditional ones, but I expect that in a variation.  It was nice to see Lizzy not so self-assured and have some doubts like a normal person.  I also adored Darcy's personality here--less brooding and more take-charge.  To be sure, there's quite a bit of strife for the first half of the book because characters won't open up to each other and take body language the wrong way, but that's essentially a lot of what happens in the original, so I was ok with it.  And thankfully the sexy scenes were well-written and integrated well.  It was fun to see the characters get swept up in passion and progress beyond kissing early in the book!  Darcy is much more of the romantic hero here than he comes across in the original, quite swoon-worthy were I inclined to swooning.