I give it three stars because "it is what it is". It's a theft deterrent, and it might stop the lower level car thief looking for a joy ride, or an amateur, but a professional (or even someone who simply knows what to do) can easily cut through the steering wheel and slip the Club right off. You can look on YouTube of videos of people removing the Club from steering wheels, one of them is simply whacking on it with a hammer and it opens. Also, the Club provides a thief with leverage to help him remove the steering wheel altogether, and put on his own! A better option would be a "brake lock" which slips around your brake pedal and prevents it from being used, very hard to remove.