I bought this case to fit my iPhone 4 with a Otterbox Defender case. I liked that it had a loop in addition to the belt clasp. I used the loop for about 2 months before it broke loose. The phone fits nicely but the velcro flap is now not staying closed. I improvised the loop by using a key ring on the belt clasp and then a carabiner bewteen my belt loop and the key ring. Overall I'd say the quality is typical Chinese.