This idea is great for guest's powder room, or any bathroom. As mentioned in other reviews, there is a chemical odor. However, the chemical odor in the one I received is not as strong as some mentioned and I could only smell it when I removed the top to sniff. I am going to throw in a few cedar chips before I install and put in the paper towels. I really like the design, but the top is thin, like 1/8" luan board or something, so I wouldn't put anything heavy atop. So why the 4 stars and not 5? The idea and the design garnered 4 stars. The lack of 5 stars is the high price. I know, so why did I purchase it at the high price? I didn't, I used my Amazon reward points, which brought the price down on my whole order.