Body glove works the best.  Hands down.  Drop the phone..... Body glove takes the beating and your phone survives the drop.  Lasts about two years and then I've had to replace them due to normal wear and tear.  All in all they just work.  I work hard and so does body glove....  Thanks body glove for making a great product we can count on.  Not plastic that only lasts a month and then ya throw it away.