Great phone case for the Galaxy 4 with the thick Otterbox protective case! My hubby works construction and needed a phone case that was vertical and had the belt loop and was canvas, this phone fits the bill on all accounts! Some reviews said case was cheap, but for the money I paid, I did not think that way and I bought 5 of them to have extras on hand. Hubby is so happy with case as it fits his Galaxy 4 with the thick Otterbox cover comfortably! He says thay he doesn't even know he's carrying it as it is so comfortable in the vertical position instead of horizontal. Some reviews talked about removing the metal belt hook, but hubby said it didn't bother him. Also love the wide opening and heavy velcro flap to secure phone safely! Even with the thicker otterbox cover the phone slkdes in and out of the case with ease! Can't say enough, just love this case for the Galaxy4 with Otterbox cover!