I had ordered another case & holster & was quite dissappointed. Had heard many positive comments about the OtterBox Defender with Holster, so I bought it. I am very happy with it. Of course, it adds some weight & bulk, but small price to pay for protection. The holster has operated well allowing me to insert the phone facing out or in and providing an easy, secure & handy way to keep it with me at all times. The only slight drawback is that the film covering does not fit firmly against the keys contributing to errors in typing sometimes. (But I'm not a perfect typist anyway) All said, I wouldn't give it up & would buy it again in a minute if ii was necessasy.