[['elector', 'place of birth', 'cardinalatial title', 'elevated', 'elevator'], ['paolo scolari', 'rome', 'bishop of palestrina', 'september 21 , 1179', 'alexander iii'], ['thibaud , osbcluny', 'france', 'bishop of ostia e velletri', '1184', 'lucius iii'], ['laborante de panormo', 'pontormo', 'priest of s maria in trastevere', 'september 1173', 'alexander iii'], ['melior le maitre , osbvall', 'pisa', 'priest of ss giovanni e paolo', 'march 16 , 1185', 'lucius iii'], ['giacinto bobone orsini', 'rome', 'deacon of s maria in cosmedin', 'december 22 , 1144', 'lucius ii'], ['graziano da pisa', 'pisa', 'deacon of ss cosma e damiano', 'march 4 , 1178', 'alexander iii'], ['ottaviano di paoli', 'rome', 'deacon of ss sergio e bacco', 'december 18 , 1182', 'lucius iii'], ['pietro diana', 'piacenza', 'deacon of s nicola in carcere', 'march 16 , 1185', 'lucius iii'], ['radulf nigellus', 'probably france', 'deacon of s giorgio in velabro', 'march 16 , 1185', 'lucius iii']]
the Cardinalatial Title for Paolo Scolari is Bishop Of Palestrina and Thibaud , Osbcluny for Bishop Of Ostia E Velletri
the [ENT] for [ENT] is [ENT] and [ENT] for [ENT]