Learning a joint language-visual embedding has a number of very appealing properties and can result in variety of practical application, including natural language image video annotation and search. In this work, we study three different joint language-visual neural network model architectures. We evaluate our models on large scale LSMDC16 movie dataset for two tasks: 1) Standard Ranking for video annotation and retrieval 2) Our proposed movie multiple-choice test. This test facilitate automatic evaluation of visual-language models for natural language video annotation based on human activities. In addition to original Audio Description (AD) captions, provided as part of LSMDC16, we collected and will make available a) manually generated re-phrasings of those captions obtained using Amazon MTurk b) automatically generated human activity elements in "Predicate + Object" (PO) phrases based on "Knowlywood", an activity knowledge mining model. Our best model archives Recall@10 of 19.2 on annotation and 18.9 on video retrieval tasks for subset of 1000 samples. For multiple-choice test, our best model achieve accuracy 58.11 over whole LSMDC16 public test-set.
@cite_19: In [, 2013], we establish a ranking-based framework for sentence-based image description and retrieval. We introduce a new dataset of images paired with multiple descriptive captions that was specifically designed for these tasks. We also present strong KCCA-based baseline systems for description and search, and perform an in-depth study of evaluation metrics for these two tasks. Our results indicate that automatic evaluation metrics for our ranking-based tasks are more accurate and robust than those proposed for generation-based image description.
@cite_18: Inspired by recent advances in multimodal learning and machine translation, we introduce an encoder-decoder pipeline that learns (a): a multimodal joint embedding space with images and text and (b): a novel language model for decoding distributed representations from our space. Our pipeline effectively unifies joint image-text embedding models with multimodal neural language models. We introduce the structure-content neural language model that disentangles the structure of a sentence to its content, conditioned on representations produced by the encoder. The encoder allows one to rank images and sentences while the decoder can generate novel descriptions from scratch. Using LSTM to encode sentences, we match the state-of-the-art performance on Flickr8K and Flickr30K without using object detections. We also set new best results when using the 19-layer Oxford convolutional network. Furthermore we show that with linear encoders, the learned embedding space captures multimodal regularities in terms of vector space arithmetic e.g. *image of a blue car* - "blue" + "red" is near images of red cars. Sample captions generated for 800 images are made available for comparison.
@cite_20: 
@cite_2: Hypernymy, textual entailment, and image captioning can be seen as special cases of a single visual-semantic hierarchy over words, sentences, and images. In this paper we advocate for explicitly modeling the partial order structure of this hierarchy. Towards this goal, we introduce a general method for learning ordered representations, and show how it can be applied to a variety of tasks involving images and language. We show that the resulting representations improve performance over current approaches for hypernym prediction and image-caption retrieval.
Image-Caption Retrieval: Another alternative is image-caption retrieval that has been defined as a standard way to evaluate joint language-visual models @cite_19 @cite_18 @cite_20 @cite_2 . The core idea is to rank a set of images according to their relevance to a caption query ( a.k.a , image retrieval) or ranking captions according to their relevance to the given image query ( a.k.a , caption retrieval). Image-caption retrieval approaches, typically, learn a joint embedding space that minimizes a pair-wise ranking objective function between images and captions. Particularly relevant to our paper, is the work of @cite_2 , where it is acknowledged that different forms of captions form a visual-semantic hierarchy and the order-preserving constraints are used as objective for learning.