We study randomized and quantum efficiency lower bounds in communication complexity. These arise from the study of zero-communication protocols in which players are allowed to abort. Our scenario is inspired by the physics setup of Bell experiments, where two players share a predefined entangled state but are not allowed to communicate. Each is given a measurement as input, which they perform on their share of the system. The outcomes of the measurements should follow a distribution predicted by quantum mechanics; however, in practice, the detectors may fail to produce an output in some of the runs. The efficiency of the experiment is the probability that neither of the detectors fails. When the players share a quantum state, this leads to a new bound on quantum communication complexity (eff*) that subsumes the factorization norm. When players share randomness instead of a quantum state, the efficiency bound (eff), coincides with the partition bound of Jain and Klauck. This is one of the strongest lower bounds known for randomized communication complexity, which subsumes all the known combinatorial and algebraic methods including the rectangle (corruption) bound, the factorization norm, and discrepancy. The lower bound is formulated as a convex optimization problem. In practice, the dual form is more feasible to use, and we show that it amounts to constructing an explicit Bell inequality (for eff) or Tsirelson inequality (for eff*). For one-way communication, we show that the quantum one-way partition bound is tight for classical communication with shared entanglement up to arbitrarily small error.
@cite_42: We prove that several measures in communication complexity are equivalent, up to polynomial factors in the logarithm of the rank of the associated matrix: deterministic communication complexity, randomized communication complexity, information cost and zero-communication cost. This shows that in order to prove the log-rank conjecture, it suffices to show that low-rank matrices have efficient protocols in any of the aforementioned measures.
@cite_10: We show that almost all known lower bound methods for communication complexity are also lower bounds for the information complexity. In particular, we define a relaxed version of the partition bound of Jain and Klauck and prove that it lower bounds the information complexity of any function. Our relaxed partition bound subsumes all norm based methods (e.g. the ?2 method) and rectangle-based methods (e.g. the rectangle corruption bound, the smooth rectangle bound, and the discrepancy bound), except the partition bound. Our result uses a new connection between rectangles and zero-communication protocols where the players can either output a value or abort. We prove the following compression lemma: given a protocol for a function f with information complexity I, one can construct a zero-communication protocol that has non-abort probability at least 2^ -O(I) and that computes f correctly with high probability conditioned on not aborting. Then, we show how such a zero-communication protocol relates to the relaxed partition bound. We use our main theorem to resolve three of the open questions raised by Braver man. First, we show that the information complexity of the Vector in Subspace Problem is O(n^ 1 3 ), which, in turn, implies that there exists an exponential separation between quantum communication complexity and classical information complexity. Moreover, we provide an O(n) lower bound on the information complexity of the Gap Hamming Distance Problem.
@cite_17: A strong direct product theorem states that, in order to solve k instances of a problem, if we provide less than k times the resource required to compute one instance, then the probability of overall success is exponentially small in k. In this paper, we consider the model of two-way public-coin communication complexity and show a strong direct product theorem for all relations in terms of the smooth rectangle bound, introduced by Jain and Klauck as a generic lower bound method in this model. Our result therefore uniformly implies a strong direct product theorem for all relations for which an (asymptotically) optimal lower bound can be provided using the smooth rectangle bound, for example Inner Product, Greater-Than, Set-Disjointness, Gap-Hamming Distance etc. Our result also implies near optimal direct product results for several important functions and relations used to show exponential separations between classical and quantum communication complexity, for which near optimal lower bounds are provided using the rectangle bound, for example by Raz [1999], Gavinsky [2008] and Klartag and Regev [2011]. In fact we are not aware of any relation for which it is known that the smooth rectangle bound does not provide an optimal lower bound. This lower bound subsumes many of the other lower bound methods, for example the rectangle bound (a.k.a the corruption bound), the smooth discrepancy bound (a.k.a the bound) which in turn subsumes the discrepancy bound, the subdistribution bound and the conditional min-entropy bound. We show our result using information theoretic arguments. A key tool we use is a sampling protocol due to Braverman [2012], in fact a modification of it used by Kerenidis, Laplante, Lerays, Roland and Xiao [2012].
Following up on the results in this paper, @cite_10 used the notion of efficiency of zero-communication protocols to show that the information cost is bounded below by a relaxation of the partition bound which is larger than the smooth rectangle and @math bounds. Jain and Yao @cite_17 followed up with a strong direct product theorem for the communication complexity of all functions for which an optimal lower bound can be shown using the smooth rectangle bound. Using a similar notion of zero-communication protocols, Gavinski and Lovett @cite_42 showed that the log rank conjecture is equivalent to an upper bound which is polylogarithmic in the rank on the zero-communication cost. The notion of zero-communication cost that they use is the non-constant efficiency (Definition and Lemma .)