Amyloid deposition underlies a broad range of diseases including multiple neurodegenerative diseases, systemic amyloidosis and type-2 diabetes. Amyloid sensitive dyes, particularly thioflavin-T, are widely used to detect ex-vivo amyloid deposits, to monitor amyloid formation in vitro and to follow the kinetics of amyloid self-assembly. We show that the dye SYPRO-orange binds to amyloid fibrils formed by human amylin, the polypeptide responsible for islet amyloid formation in type-2 diabetes. No fluorescence enhancement is observed in the presence of pre-fibrillar species or in the presence of non-amyloidogenic rat amylin. The kinetics of human amylin amyloid formation can be monitored by SYPRO-orange fluorescence and match the time course determined with thioflavin-T assays. Thus, SYPRO-orange offers an alternative to thioflavin-T assays of amylin amyloid formation. The implications for the interpretation of SYPRO-orange-based assays of protein stability and protein-ligand interactions are discussed.