Discrimination of isomeric methylated metabolites is an important step toward identifying genes responsible for methylation, but presents substantial challenges because authentic standards are often unavailable and mass spectra of isomers have been considered indistinguishable. In this report, an approach is described for identifying methyl group positions in multiply methylated flavonoid metabolites using combinations of tandem mass spectrometry, liquid chromatography retention, and site-selective methylation by recombinant O-methyltransferases from Solanum habrochaites LA1777. The basis for observed fragment ions in tandem mass spectra of multiply methylated myricetin was further established using enzymatic incorporation of deuterium-labeled methyl groups using S-adenosylmethionine-d(3) as precursor.