Title: formation of modern american culture » Blog Archive » Andrew Carnegie and The Gospel of Wealth
Headings: formation of modern american culture
formation of modern american culture
Andrew Carnegie and The Gospel of Wealth
6 Responses to “Andrew Carnegie and The Gospel of Wealth”
Leave a Reply
Pages

Content: It is contentious to claim such an opinion because although it is hard to argue that Carnegie’s actions and ideas have been harmful to American society; it is also however important to see in what ways has it been beneficial, and in particular, to what groups of people have benefited from such philanthropic actions. And more abstractly, what is Carnegie saying about the poor/working classes of America? While I understand Carnegie’s desire to ameliorate American poverty through education reform, public work funds, and other charity organizations, it is problematic in the way he views the role of the people who will be directly affected by his philanthropic measures. His staunch belief that philanthropy and the allocation of surplus funds is the sole role of the wealthy classes not only breaths a negative sense of “Social Darwinism”, but also undermines the intellectual capabilities of the lower classes. It is not to say that Carnegie’s intentions were bad, but by demeaning the intellect of the lower class, he is failing to understand the holistic system of philanthropy. In order for philanthropy to work at its best form, the people who are receiving the contributions must have some sort of say and position regarding the allocation of funds. Otherwise, the wealthy will continue to assist organizations and groups that support their worldview, beliefs, code of ethics, and values. Undermining the control and capability of the poor can do as much harm as good, even if the intentions were not to do so. Log in to Reply
Daniel Sundali says: