; and (B) shall select to be conducted— (i) the qualified forest management activity, as approved by the Secretary; or (ii) a proposal submitted by an objector or an intervening party. (2) Selection criteria An arbitrator shall, when selecting a proposal, consider— (A) whether the proposal is consistent with the applicable forest plan, laws, and regulations; (B) whether the proposal can be carried out by the Secretary concerned; and (C) the effect of each proposal on— (i) forest health; (ii) potential losses of life and property; (iii) habitat diversity; (iv) wildfire potential; (v) insect and disease potential; (vi) timber production; and (vii) the implications of a resulting decline in forest health, loss of habitat diversity, wildfire, or insect or disease infestation, given fire and insect and disease historic cycles, on— (I) potential losses of life and property; (II) domestic water costs; (III) wildlife habitat loss; and (IV) other economic and social factors. (e) Effect of decision The decision of an arbitrator with respect to the qualified forest management activity shall— (1) not be considered a major Federal action; (2) be binding