Assistant Commissioner shall determine a process to carry out such assessments, including projected milestones and completion dates for addressing data reliability issues and, as necessary, correcting data weaknesses, in order that U.S. Customs and Border Protection can produce accurate and reliable annual assessments that can be compared year-to-year. (2) Elements Each annual assessment conducted pursuant to paragraph (1) shall at a minimum include the following: (A) The average reduced security exam rate by CTPAT program participant tier and entity type. (B) The average reduction in penalties for CTPAT program participants by tier and entity type. (C) The average reduction in risk assessment for CTPAT program participants by tier and entity type. (3) Public availability The Executive Assistant Commissioner shall make each annual assessment publicly available on the CTPAT portal for at least one year. (c) Consultation When assessing benefits in accordance with subsection (b), the Executive Assistant Commissioner shall consult with the Commercial Customs Operations Advisory Committee established under section 109 of the Trade Facilitation and Trade Enforcement Act of 2015 ( Public Law 114–125