; and (B) shall select to be conducted— (i) the forest management activity, as approved by the Secretary; or (ii) a proposal submitted by an objector or an intervening party. (2) Selection criteria An arbitrator shall, when selecting a proposal, consider— (A) whether the proposal is consistent with the applicable forest plan, laws, and regulations; (B) whether the proposal can be carried out by the Secretary concerned; and (C) the effect of each proposal on— (i) forest health; (ii) habitat diversity; (iii) wildfire potential; (iv) insect and disease potential; (v) timber production; and (vi) the implications of a resulting decline in forest health, loss of habitat diversity, wildfire, or insect or disease infestation, given fire and insect and disease historic cycles, on— (I) domestic water costs; (II) wildlife habitat loss; and (III) other economic and social factors. (e) Effect of decision The decision of an arbitrator with respect to the forest management activity— (1) shall not be considered a major Federal action; (2) shall be binding