Kirksey v. Kirksey
Introduction '''''Kirksey v. Kirksey''''', Ala. Sup. 8 Ala. 131 (1845), was a case decided by the Supreme Court of Alabama that held that a promise by a man, Issac Kirksey,  to give his sister-in-law a house if she would move to his land was not a valid contract because it lacked bargained-for-consideration.The trial was initiated in Talladega, Alabama.
Background The plaintiff Antillico Kirksey was a widow living in a lease-to-own home. After learning of his brother and nephew's deaths, the defendant wrote the following letter to his sister-in-law Antillico:Antillico relied on a promise from her brother-in-law and subsequently gave up her leased home. This home would become her opportunity cost when she moved into her brother-in-law's home.
Decision After receiving the letter from her brother-in-law, the plaintiff moved to the defendant's farm, but the defendant kicked her out after two years, forcing her to live in a dilapidated house in the woods.Thus, the plaintiff sued to enforce the promise, but the court did not find a valid contract. It held that a promise on the condition, "if you will come down and see me" is not a bargained for exchange for the promisee's "coming down to see" the promisor. The promise is not sufficiently supported by bargained-for consideration and is not enforceable.Justice John James Ormond issued a dissenting opinion in this case.
Legal analysis Samuel Williston has opined that the plaintiff should have been allowed to invoke a promissory estoppel which allows plaintiffs to demand remedy for misleading promises. The idea of a "promissory estoppel" had not been fashioned at the time of the ''Kirksey'' holding which could have addressed the injustice experienced by the plaintiff. The injustice was based on detrimental reliance on a broken promise.
See also *''Hoffman v. Red Owl Stores, Inc.'', 1965, Supreme Court of Wisconsin*700 F. 2d 916 - ''Vastoler v. American Can Company'', 1983, United States Court of Appeals, Third Circuit
References
External links * Casto,W.R. & Ricks, V.D. ''"Dear Sister Antillico": The story of Kirksey v. Kirksey'', 94 Geo. L.J. 321, 383 (2006)