Inhibition of human DNA topoisomerase II\xce\xb1 by two novel ellipticine derivatives
Ellipticine (5,11-dimethyl-6H-pyrido[4,3-b]carbazole) is an antineoplastic agent that intercalates into DNA and alters topoisomerase II activity. Unfortunately, this compound displays a number of adverse properties. Therefore, to investigate new ellipticine-based compounds for their potential as topoisomerase II-targeted drugs, we synthesized two novel derivatives, N-methyl-5-demethyl ellipticine (ET-1) and 2-methyl-N-methyl-5-demethyl ellipticinium iodide (ET-2). As determined by DNA decatenation and cleavage assays, ET-1 and ET-2 act as catalytic inhibitors of human topoisomerase II\xce\xb1 and are both more potent than the parent compound. Neither compound impairs the ability of the type II enzyme to bind its DNA substrate. Finally, the potency of ET-1 and ET-2 as catalytic inhibitors of topoisomerase II\xce\xb1 appears to be related to their ability to intercalate into the double helix.
<p>Type II topoisomerases have been important enzyme targets for medicinal and chemotherapeutic agents since the identification of amsacrine as a topoisomerase II-targeted anticancer drug in 1984.1 Since that time, an increasing number of naturally occurring and synthetic compounds of pharmacological importance have been reported to exert their activities by interfering with DNA topoisomerase II function.2–12 Although lower eukaryotic species encode only one type II topoisomerase, vertebrates encode two closely related isoforms of the enzyme, topoisomerase IIα and IIβ.13–18 These enzymes play essential roles in a number of genetic processes, including DNA replication, transcription, and recombination, as well as chromosome segregation.13–18 Type II topoisomerases resolve the problems associated with the topological constraints of the genetic material (i.e., DNA under- or overwinding, knotting, and tangling) by transiently cleaving both strands of the double helix.13–18</p><p>Topoisomerase II-targeted agents act in one of two manners.14,15,19–24
Topoisomerase II poisons kill cells by increasing levels of covalent topoisomerase II-cleaved DNA complexes. All of the clinically relevant topoisomerase II poisons examined to date do so by interfering with the ability of the enzyme to religate cleaved DNA molecules.14,15,19,20,22–24 Alternatively, topoisomerase II catalytic inhibitors act by robbing the cell of the essential catalytic functions of the type II enzymes.19–21,23 Catalytic inhibitors have been shown to act at a variety of steps of the topoisomerase II catalytic cycle, including DNA cleavage.19–21,23</p><p>Ellipticine (5,11-dimethyl-6H-pyrido[4,3-b]carbazole), a natural product first isolated from the Australian evergreen tree, is an antineoplastic agent that intercalates into DNA and alters topoisomerase II activity.1,25–32 The compound is a mild poison against topoisomerase II from Drosophila and Saccharomyces cerevisiae.29,30 However, most studies report that ellipticine induces little, if any, DNA cleavage mediated by mammalian type II topoisomerases and inhibits enzyme activity at higher concentrations.1,27–29 In contrast to the parent compound, several ellipticine derivatives are potent topoisomerase II poisons in mammalian systems and display anticancer activity against human breast cancer and other solid tumors.26,32,33 Unfortunately, these compounds induce a number of adverse effects such as dry mouth, weight loss, hemolysis, and renal toxicity. Moreover, the parent compound, ellipticine, displays poor water solubility and target specificity, and drug resistance has been observed upon prolonged administration.27,34–36</p><p>The activities of hydroxylated and N-alkylated ellipticine analogs have been described previously.32,33 However, the properties of C5 demethylated compounds have not been analyzed. Thus, in an effort to investigate new ellipticine-based compounds for their potential as topoisomerase II-targeted drugs, we synthesized two novel derivatives, N-methyl-5-demethyl ellipticine (ET-1) and 2-methyl-N-methyl-5-demethyl ellipticinium iodide (ET-2). Ellipticine derivatives were synthesized via a novel pathway shown in Fig. 1. The detailed syntheses and physical and chemical characterizations of ET-1 and ET-2 are described in the accompanying Supplementary Data.</p><p>Briefly, ET-1 and ET-2 were generated using a nine-step synthetic pathway with a 12% overall yield (Fig. 1). First, 4,9-dimethyl-9H-carbazole-3-carbaldehyde (1) was synthesized in five steps, according to the literature, starting from Hagemann's ester (ethyl-2-methyl-4-oxocyclohex-2-enecarboxylate).37,38 We then generated N-methyl-5-demethyl ellipticine (ET-1) and 2-methyl-N-methyl-5-demethyl ellipticinium iodide (ET-2) in four subsequent steps.39 Aldehyde 1 was treated with aminoacetaldehyde diethylacetal in solvent-free conditions to yield imine 2. The imine was reduced with sodium borohydride to produce amine 3, which was treated with benzene sulfonyl chloride to produce sulfonamide 4. Finally, cyclization of ET-1 was achieved by treating sulfonamide 4 with hydrochloric acid in dioxane. ET-2 was obtained by treating ET-1 with iodomethane in dimethyl formamide. Stock solutions of the test compounds (50 mM) were prepared in DMSO. ET-1 and ET-2 both were more soluble than ellipticine.</p><p>A number of assays were utilized to compare the effects of ET-1 and ET-2 on human topoisomerase IIα with those of the parent compound, ellipticine. First, the effects of the compounds on the overall catalytic activity of the enzyme were monitored using a decatenation assay (Fig. 2). Both ET-1 and ET-2 inhibited the ability of topoisomerase IIα to unlink kinetoplast DNA (kDNA) rings and blocked enzyme activity completely at concentrations of 200–1000 μM. In contrast, ellipticine required a concentration of >5000 μM to completely inhibit the decatenation activity of the type II enzyme.</p><p>Although topoisomerase II poisons act by enhancing levels of DNA cleavage, they still have the capacity to inhibit overall enzyme activity.19,40 Therefore, to determine whether ET-1 and ET-2 act specifically as catalytic inhibitors or also have the capacity to act as topoisomerase II poisons, their effects on topoisomerase IIα-mediated DNA cleavage were assessed (Fig. 3). As reported previously, ellipticine was a modest inhibitor of DNA cleavage (IC50 >200 μM).1,28 Neither ET-1 nor ET-2 enhanced topoisomerase IIα-mediated DNA cleavage and both inhibited the DNA scission activity of the enzyme to a much greater extent than ellipticine. The IC50 for the two compounds were ~40 and 5 μM, respectively.</p><p>Catalytic inhibitors can block enzyme activity at a number of different steps of the topoisomerase II catalytic cycle.19–21 Compounds that inhibit the enzyme have been shown to act by blocking DNA binding, cleavage, or strand passage, or by interfering with ATP binding/hydrolysis. Because ET-1 and ET-2 inhibited DNA cleavage, we examined the effects of these compounds on topoisomerase IIα-DNA binding to determine whether the compounds are specific for DNA cleavage or act at a prior step in the catalytic cycle. ET-1 and ET-2 were used at 25 μM for this experiment, because DNA cleavage was inhibited substantially (~40 and 80% inhibition, respectively) at this concentration. Enzyme-DNA binding was monitored using an electrophoretic mobility shift assay (Fig. 4). Neither ET-1 nor ET-2 displayed any ability to inhibit topoisomerase IIα-DNA binding at the concentration employed. In fact, ET-2 appeared to enhance enzyme-DNA binding by ~50%. Thus, we conclude that ET-1 and ET-2 inhibit DNA cleavage without altering the ability of topoisomerase IIα to bind its DNA substrate.</p><p>The ability of ellipticine to intercalate into DNA appears to play an important role in its antineoplastic activity.36 Because ET-1 and ET-2 are more potent inhibitors of human topoisomerase IIα than ellipticine, a topoisomerase I-DNA unwinding assay was utilized to compare the ability of these compounds to intercalate into relaxed plasmid DNA (Fig. 5). As determined by the shift in the plasmid from relaxed to negatively supercoiled DNA, all of the compounds intercalated into DNA. Similar to the inhibition of DNA cleavage observed with the compounds (see Fig. 3), the relative potency of intercalation was ET-2>ET-1≫ellipticine. This finding suggests that the ability of the ellipticine derivatives to inhibit the activity of topoisomerase IIα is related to their ability to intercalate into the double helix.</p><p>There is a need for the development of new anticancer drugs. Given the demonstrated antineoplastic activity of ellipticine, derivatives of this compound have the potential to display greater activity against cells or enzyme targets.32,41,42 Results of the present study indicate that ET-1 and ET-2 are catalytic inhibitors of human topoisomerase IIα. Furthermore, both are more potent than ellipticine, and the activity of ET-1 and ET-2 toward the type II enzyme appears to be related to their enhanced ability to intercalate into DNA.</p>