Carson sung Remy's favorite songs that she had practiced for choir auditions, he  knows she was practicing them.
I feel like crap but I did not know Remy was doing the same song. Really! I did not know. You are full of crap, Carson. No one does Tom Waits songs like Remy does. No one knows who Tom Waits is. But he's my favorite. I was just trying to be unique. You know Remy only listens to Tom Waits. You bought her the box-set for Christmas, you idiot!!! Oh yeah. That's why I could not get those tunes out of my head. And now you just lost your Jersey Girl forever!!