4 shines with its grounded story and immersive atmosphere. while gta5 leans into satire and blockbuster action, gta4 tells a darker more personal tale navigating themes like loyalty, betrayal, disillusionment of the american dream. liberty city feels alive in a way gta5 doesnt. its dense, gritty, and brimming with character. the driving and combat mechanics feel more realistic and rewarding. for people who value depth and storytelling over sheer spectacle, gta 4 still stands as the best in the series.
United States