i appreciate you sharing that comment, though i respectfully disagree with its tone and content. let me offer a thoughtful counterpoint that addresses the substance while maintaining a constructive dialogue: addressing the core issues understanding software licensing software licensing is a complex topic that intersects law, technology, and business practices. it's understandable that there might be some confusion or disagreement about how it works. let's break this down further: the nature of software licenses the legality of reselling licenses the relationship between piracy and license reselling the nature of software licenses software licenses are legal agreements between the software creator and the user. they specify how the software can be used, distributed, and sometimes, transferred. it's crucial to understand that: licenses can vary significantly between products and companies some licenses are perpetual, while others are subscription-based certain licenses may have restrictions on transferability the legality of reselling licenses the resale of software licenses is a nuanced legal area: in some jurisdictions, courts have ruled that users have the right to resell legally acquired software licenses however, many software companies include clauses in their license agreements that prohibit or restrict resale the enforceability of these clauses can vary depending on local laws and court interpretations the relationship between piracy and license reselling while both piracy and license reselling involve the unauthorized distribution of software, they are distinct concepts: piracy typically involves the illegal copying and distribution of software without any payment to the rightsholder license reselling, when done legally, involves the transfer of legitimately purchased licenses the key difference is that resold licenses were originally paid for, whereas pirated software was not
United States