 I got the '09 M3i, 2.0 manual.  I deliver pizza and do a lot of driving. I've driven nice cars; a porche, some bmw's and a few other nice cars so I'm trying to be completely objective with my review and will break down my scoring on the scale above.  Performance: zippy, but not real fast, can't hang with the big boys but the handling is superb, which brought the score up to a 7/10.  Comfort:  I drive for HOURS!  I'm never uncomfortable. 7/10. Fuel economy:  I avg 27 mpg...depending on the use of AC and if i'm driving like a maniac which i sometimes do.  350-290 miles per tank.(usually around 320). 7/10.  Fun to drive:  that the handling is so surprisingly responsive combined 