 The basic S model in the 4 door with cloth interior is a great value.  The beige interior with brushed aluminum trim looks very upscale and the materials feel expensive.  The 15 inch wheel contribute greatly to ride comfort over the broken pavement and pot holes and the car still tracked well.  It feels solid and well put together.  Its quiet and smooth and easy to see out of.   I drove the Jetta Sport in a five speed and I was disappointed.  That particular Jetta also seems to have been abused as a demo so it might not be representative.  Then I drove the Golf 6 speed auto and what a difference. If VW offered a 6 speed manual in the TSI I would have no hesitation in buying one. As it were, I am very tempted with the 6 speed auto.  The paddle shifter on the steering wheel gave it a sporting touch and they also worked very well.  Everything about the car is spot on!