 Narrowed it down to a Subaru Crostrek and the VW Golf Alltrack. In the end, the Alltrack won because of it's much stronger engine, fit and finish, and timeless style. Getting about 27mpg in mixed driving. VW dealership was willing to give a great deal...$4,500 off of MSRP. I encourage you to at least give the Alltrack a drive before you make a final decision. Pay attention to the amazing transmission (DSG) and power the turbo 4 has in comparison to Subaru's 4 banger. There is no comparison...the Alltrack is amazing!