 After 40,000 miles and almost 3 years with my 6MT G, I still love it.  I drove an 05 BMW 330 the other day and it certainly was better in some ways but its just a little too bland compared to the G.  The tire life and road noise are the only real downsides.  Hopefully more tires will become available for the 19" wheels in the future.  Need some touring compound tires that will last more then 20k.  The transmission was just replaced under warranty because the 6th gear syncro was out.  Otherwise no problems.  avg 24-25mpg with a mix of hwy and city driving.  (the benefits of a man.trans)