URL Structure - advise and thoughts of best approach? I am currently building a website for Hot Tubs and within this there will be New Tubs, Used Tubs and Hire Tubs (each will be a top level page on the navigation, and each tub will have a details page). Each tub will only exist in one of the three sections. The templates will be different and so I have decided to go for 3 individual channels.

However, any thoughts from a URL structure/SEO etc on the different approaches to URLS for sections.
I am thinking of either keeping them all separate like so:

www.domain.co.uk/used-hot-tubs/  
www.domain.co.uk/used-hot-tubs/name-of-used-tub/ 

www.domain.co.uk/hot-tubs/  
www.domain.co.uk/hot-tubs/name-of-new-tub/  

www.domain.co.uk/hot-tubs-for-hire/  
www.domain.co.uk/hot-tubs-for-hire/name-of-hire-tub/


Or whether they should all be structure like so?  

www.domain.co.uk/hot-tubs/used/  
www.domain.co.uk/hot-tubs/used/name-of-used-tub/

www.domain.co.uk/hot-tubs/new/  
www.domain.co.uk/hot-tubs/new/name-of-new-tub/ 

www.domain.co.uk/hot-tubs/hire/  
www.domain.co.uk/hot-tubs/hire/name-of-hire-tub/  


or

www.domain.co.uk/used/
www.domain.co.uk/used/name-of-used-tub/

www.domain.co.uk/new/
www.domain.co.uk/new/name-of-new-tub/

www.domain.co.uk/hire/
www.domain.co.uk/hire/name-of-hire-tub/


Any input/thoughts appreciated….

EDIT: I should add this is not an eCommerce website, although the structure could lends itself to that and that the top level domain does contain the words hottubs.
I’d go for /hot-tubs/used etc

This way you can also have /accessories/pipes etc