Catalytic Carbon or Birm for iron removal
I ended up getting something with Iron Rival Light media.
After researching a bit, and finding something that I don't remember the name, but it was created in Germany and said to work better than Filox, Birm or Carbon; but it led me to a company selling a filter with this media and it has this write-up:


  Iron Rival Light is a revolutionary new light weight
  iron treatment media that is best described as a cross between Birm
  and Filox. As such, it shares the best characteristics of both media.
  Being a coated media and light weight, Iron Rival light is easier to
  backwash - it requires less flow rate to backwash and it does not need
  to be done as often as Filox. Yet, the coating and volume of active
  ingredient (10% manganese dioxide) is much greater than that of Birm,
  resulting in longer media life and increased performance. Iron Rival
  Light has a recommended pH level of 6.0 to 9.0 and effectively
  removes, iron, manganese, and hydrogen sulfide.


After getting it setup, the water is coming out completely clean!