Switch with 2 black wires and 1 white
This may not be the ideal solution but I did get it connected an working.  I did not realize that I could put more than one of the wires on a single screw on the switch.  Once I figured this out, I simply connected the formerly backstabbed wires to their corresponding screws and doubling up on the screw that already had a wire on it.
Thanks for the help, and if you have suggestions on making it better, let me know.