Receiving "The SELECT permission was denied on the object" even though it's been granted
I'm not sure here, but I'm going to go out on a limb.  I think your issue might be with your DENY CONTROL record.  See here about half way down the page:

Denying CONTROL permission on a database implicitly denies CONNECT permission on the database. A principal that is denied CONTROL permission on a database will not be able to connect to that database.

I realize that example is for a database, but take it one more granual level.  A DENY CONTROL on a table will deny all privileges on it, I'm guessing.  Do a REVOKE CONTROL to get rid of that and see if that fixes your issue.

If so, you'll have to place the user in a database role or deny them the explicit privileges against the table.