Trying to import a large sql file using BigDump. Partial fail occuring
I finally found the actual problem! It had nothing to do with how I was importing it, it was my local server's export that failed halfway through!

After opening up VIM and going to the end of the file, I found: Fatal error: Maximum execution time of 300 seconds exceeded...

Ahhhh, the problem was with my local server's timeout, so it only exported a partial amount of the data.