Re-run a specific actual query plan
Yes.

You need the USE PLAN hint.

In which you supply the XML from the first plan.

SELECT *
FROM T
OPTION (USE PLAN N'&lt;?xml version="1.0" encoding="utf-16"?&gt; ....')


Whilst it doesn't guarantee that the plan will be exactly the same (e.g. compute scalar operators can move around for example) it will likely be pretty close.