Ancheer 250watt Motor Hall Sensors?
You most likely need digital hall sensors (instead of analog versions). Most bldc motors use digital hall sensors. You should check your controller specs to see what type of hall sensors it supports but most likely you will need digital.

have you tried testing the hall sensors with either a multimeter or controller tester to see if they  switch on and off when rotating the wheel? Are you sure your hall sensor leads are correctly connected to the controller? Is there voltage on to the GND and +5V wires going to the hall sensors? (Measure voltage across these two wires when the controller is turned on, the motor doesn't have to be moving for this.
Are you sure you didn't damage your hall sensors during installation?

Is there any other text/marking(brand perhaps) on the original hall sensors? Could you attach a/some photo(s) of the original hall sensors for reference?