What should be evaluated in food decomposition experiment?
You could weigh the cookies in a time course to see how quickly the cookies are degraded. Also, you could take some samples and make cultures in Petri dishes to see if there are differences in the microbiota associated with each one. In this line, maybe you'd want to sterilize the samples by some means, just to ensure they have the same microbial conditions. You could also measure the porosity of the samples by pacing them in water and measure how much water it can absorb, or something like that. I assume you do not have an HPLC engine, but you could also make extracts and see how the spectra varies over time.