Multiple numbers in the Ishihara test?
The Ishihara Color Test consists of plates containing one number. But that number may consist of two digits (Fig. 1). After scouring the internet I have also found variants of the test where the each of the two digit had a different coloring (Fig. 2), but these tests may not all be validated/standardized or used by health care professionals. The plates may also contain one or two wiggly lines that have to be traced (Fig.1). In all, my conclusion is that there are many variants of this specific test around, at least on the web. I am not aware whether there are certain standardized versions being used by health care professionals. In all, my answer to your question... 


  Were there slides in the test that had two or more numbers, or was I hallucinating?


...is that there might have been two digits of different coloring in the plate, dependent on the specific make of your teacher's plates. You might, or might not have been hallucinating. To give a more affirmative answer, the specific test with the specific make would have been dug up by your teacher. 


Fig. 1. Ishihara test with a plate containing one number of two digits (left) and one or more wiggly lines (right). source: Colour Blindness


Fig. 2. Ishihara variants, showing two digits with different shades in the middle panel. source: allinesnowmop, a personal web page, credibility questionable