Mac Chrome Scrolling issue (followed many guides, none have worked, video showing problem included))
After explaining my situation to my co-worker and explaining that I was not experiencing these issues in Incognito, he pointed out that extensions are disabled in incognito.  This was my issue, I had an extension that was added a long time ago that affected scrolling, and google synced it with my new install.   If you are having these issues in this day and age, be sure to disable your extensions at Chrome://extensions and see if this resolves your issue! :)