Bode is plot despite of high quality factor
First, I'm setting aside the fact that a \$1\mathrm{pF}\$ cap just isn't realizable in practice on a circuit board.  The input capacitance to the op-amp is probably greater than that.  There's a reason it's hard to find capacitors with values less than \$4.7\mathrm{pF}\$ or so.
You are doing your calculations assuming an ideal op-amp.  However, the expected peak for your filter is going to be in the neighborhood of \$16\mathrm{MHz}\$ (give or take a factor of \$\sqrt{2}\$ or \$\sqrt{3}\$).  At the same time, the gain bandwidth product of your op-amp is only \$700\mathrm{kHz}\$.
Basically, not only is your op-amp not ideal at the design frequency, it's not even really an op-amp.
You could use an op-amp that has a gain of at least 100 at your design frequency -- but using \$10\mathrm{k}\Omega\$ resistors and \$1\mathrm{pF}\$ caps in a circuit that needs to be good up to a \$\mathrm{GHz}\$ is just not going to work.