Active Bandpass Filter Design Issues
There are several different active bandpass topologies available. The most common are Sallen-Key and Multi-Feedback. Show us your first attempt - so we can discuss on a realistic basis. 
If you are a newcomer in filter design I urgently recommend to use on of the filter design programs (online or downloadable). But note that you need a clear specification (filter order, mid-frequency, bandwidth resp. Q-value). And - if possible - use split supply only!

Selecting a suitable opamp should not be a problem in your case because the operational frequency range is sufficiently low (by the way: Don`t care about common-mode input voltage ranges). Most probably you got "strange" results (negative dB values) because the opamps were not powered correctly (single supply).