Using op-amp at high or low end of Vcc range
They will both work off the total 5 V you have available, so without knowing more about your application, either will do.
If you want to find a 'best', or an 'only', then you'll have to trawl through the other parameters until you find one that completely disqualifies the part.
These parameters are very different (more than 2:1 ratio) between the two

typical and maximum bias current
slew rate
output current
noise when near the +ve rail

The killer may be that the TLV has crossover distortion around an input voltage 3 V below the top rail. However, it's only a few 10s of μV, so the precision of your application will determine whether that rules the part out, or is insignificant.