Inverting Second Order Filter
Answering my own question:

It would seem that multiple feedback filters do exactly what I was looking for, somehow missed them in my search (curses to the abundance of Sallen Keys). I will also be pursuing a higher order filter because, as pointed out, the noise reduction isn't all that great due to the relative proximity of my noise source and desired pass band. Again, thanks @TonyStewartolderthandirt for the helpful guidance.

As it may help others, I also came across this tool, which shows the response of multiple filter types and orders very nicely: http://www.analog.com/designtools/en/filterwizard/