KiCad component doesn't match manufacturers model
The official library (the library that comes with a KiCad installation) focuses on the core usecase of KiCad which is PCB design. This means the symbols are made to best fit that usecase. (The pin numbers are chosen to fit the footprint meant for this symbol. Footprint pad numbers come from industry standards like JEDEC.)
Simulation is supported by special symbols placed in libraries with prefix &quot;Simulation_&quot;. In your case you could use the OPAMP symbol from the Simulation_SPICE library.