What does a blue line indicate in Logisim?
A Blue wire indicates an unknown state, distinct from a not connected wire or error state, it means that the ALU component is not driving the output (e.g. invalid input or op-code).  

Blue wire is reserved for one-bit signals, an unknown state in a multi-bit bus is not indicated via wire color but is represented by an X on any output readout.

See: This Documentation Page