Lt spice op amp phase margin
Read a thread on Here that said since I'm powering the op amp 5vdc that I needed to bump the voltage input to be in between the rails.


Citation from that answer:


  As mentioned by just about everyone in the comments, your op amp doesn't work because your DC bias point is 0V and the op amp will only work for inputs between its rails (0V and 5V).


Because you use the opamp in a unity gain voltage follower configuration, the input of your opamp is the positive input terminal of the opamp.
To prevent the operating point running into the power rails, you should not short this positive input terminal of the opamp to GND, because that causes an operation point of 0V. Instead, insert a voltage source (e.g.) 2.5Vdc on it (source V5 with value {Vin} as shown below). The AC source should have an DC component that is 0Vdc.  

You can verify this by stepping the voltage of this DC voltage source V5 with .step param Vin LIST 1V 2V 3V : they should yield the same outputs for AC transient analysis.