2 separate Profile2 Views (one faculty, one staff)
You could add a field "user type" to the current profile and then add a views filter or views "contextual filter" to only show one type at a time. You may need to add a "relationship" on the profile2. 

Alternatively, profile2 lets you specify different types of profiles. So you could make a 'faculty' profile and a 'students' profile.

It really depends on what would work best in your setup.