What i5 index should I use on the Illumina sample sheet for an unindexed p5 primer?
Illumina machines read the two indices in separate index sequencing reactions where they have sequencing barcodes specific for indices. If you have no index, then you should either not bother with creating either index read or mask that during demultiplexing. If you're mixing indexed samples with an unindexed sample, you can't really rely on any particular sequence being returned by the machine (i.e., just use the "undetermined indices" fastq file). The unindexed adapters tend to not have the full index sequencing primer binding site on them, so reads without index generally don't return much signal. In practice, they're likely to adopt barcode sequences of neighboring clusters. We see that a lot when we spike in PhiX. It has no barcode but you tend to get a small amount assigned to each sample either due to index hopping or (more likely) bleed through of signal from neighboring clusters (or small amounts of those clusters walking between nanowells and then their minority signal dominating during index sequencing).