Is this a good or a bad propeller?
Engine shaft power: P = 0.58 hp, Propeller diameter: D = 8.5 ft, RPM = 245, Static thrust: T = 18.75 lbf

$\eta_{prop} = \sqrt{\frac{T^3}{(P^2 \cdot \pi \cdot \frac{D^2}{2} \cdot \rho )}} = 49.5\%$

where $\rho=1.2 \frac{kg}{m^3}$

So at an efficiency of 49.5% that propeller is rather poor.

Note: I used the formula that relates static thrust to efficiency, power and propeller diameter from here.