Gingerbread,HoneyComb,ICS ROM for Galaxy S
First of all, do not install HoneyComb on the galaxy s. HoneyComb is designed for tablets, not phones. 

Secondy most of the roms on XDA are good, just check the comments and see whats wrong with them. 

Check out this post here http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1398223 seems pretty legit, only a couple of bugs that hardly matter (check below)

Bugs:

Lockscreen occasionally does not react to touch
Formatting external sd formats internal
Facebook sync pictures are low res(but at least it works)probably not fixable from our end