Programming Arduino via ICSP
I suggest you to try and read the Arduino page about ArduinoISP.

Particularly, you will notice that pins 11, 12, 13 and Vcc and GND are all common, BUT the reset pin is not common to both boards. So I suggest you to detach the pin 5 of ICSP from the ArduinoISP board and connect it to its pin 10. Or, if you prefer, connect

ISP - Target
+5V - +5V
GND - GND
11  - 11
12  - 12
13  - 13
10  - RST


Then try again