If condition for switch not working as expected
It's hard to tell which pins of the switch do what. Since you have your inputs set up as INPUT (instead of INPUT_PULLUP) you should have a resistor (10k Ω, say) tying those pins to ground. Then the other end of switch should connect to +5V. Don't connect the switches to both +5V and ground.
Use a multimeter on continuity to make sure that the pins of the switch that you are using are open normally, and close when you press the switch. With 4 pins it's easy to get confused as to which switch pin does what.