Where can I purchase extra wood pieces for Settlers of Catan?
Replacement parts can be found from Mayfair Games, although this will match your 4th Edition color pieces. (Older editions came in different colors). If you want Seafarer's , or other sets they have those too.


  Settlers of Catan- Pieces - Set 4 player -White Blue Red and Orange with Robber ( MFGP3061-41 ) Price: $12.00


If you wanted some approximate replacements, PnP Productions has wooden ships (Seafarer's), wooden blocks (Knights &amp; Cities, city walls), plastic hotels &amp; houses (settlements/cities), and wooden cubes (roads?) in quite a few colors that differ from the original 4th Ed. colors.