How can I get the bottle glossy W/O the label too?
There is nothing wrong with your setup other than the lights and the surroundings of the bottle... Remember, glossy materials reflect the environment. So make the environment something worth reflecting...



Instead of adding a bunch of point lights, create large light sources... 

Since you are so invested in creating bottles, take some time and study how most images of glass and alcohol and beverages are lit. You'll find out soon enough that when dealing with glass most photographers have big light sources and interesting patterns to be reflected on the shiny surfaces.

One more thing to try in your setup is to use the yellow letters as a mask for  the glossy shader, so that the purple part of the label can be diffuse and only the writing has a reflective surface