how do electromeric / inductive effect theories compare with resonance
The concepts of electromeric and inductive effects are not obsolete.

Only the term "electromeric" is obsolete and has been subsumed in the terms "mesomeric effect" (+M and -M) and "resonance effect" (see iupac source). The term "isomeric effect" is still in use and I learned it not a decade ago along with "mesomeric" and "resonance".

Amusingly, your SE question is my first result in google for "Marxist chemistry". From the little I have just read in this book, Marxist chemistry had apparently more to do with refusal of the concept of resonance than anything else. So... maybe? Maybe not.