Why should this be a thrust fault?
First don't rotate the whole thing, you are just confusing yourself by rotating the bedding plane. You can't rotate the bedding planes and expect faults to match up like that. Your eye is treating the bedding plane as horizontal which makes it a completely different from of fault.
A thrust fault is just a reverse fault with a shallow fault angle.

Pay attention to how the bedding planes move relative to each other notice how they begin to double up in both forms of reverse fault, while in a normal fault sections begin to disappear in the middle, being lost from hypothetical drill core entirely. In the reverse faults if you drilled down through the blocks there are areas where you would drill through the dark central bed twice while in the normal there are places where you would never hit it at all.