Kathryn Lindskoog , an independent Lewis scholar , argued that Hooper 's scholarship is not reliable and that he made false statements and attributed counterfeit works to Lewis . Kathryn Lindskoog , an independent Lewis scholar , argued that Hooper 's scholarship is not reliable and that he has made false statements and attributed forged works to Lewis . Kathryn Lindskoog , an independent Hooper scholar , argued that Lewis 's scholarship is not reliable and that he has made false statements and attributed forged works to Lewis .