Bouck's Island is a farm near Breakabeen, New York within the town of Fulton, Schoharie County, New York near Fultonham, New York. Bouck's Island was the home of former New York governor William C. Bouck. Congressman Joseph Bouck was born on Bouck's Island and Wisconsin Congressman Gabriel Bouck once lived there.
Bouck's Island was named after Congressman Joseph Bouck.
It is incorrect because the Island couldn't have been named after him if he was born there.  That implies that the island was named after a person who had yet to be born. 