Jamar Shipman ( born April 21 , 1985 in Elizabeth , New Jersey ) is an American professional wrestler who currently wrestles for Total Nonstop Action Wrestling ( TNA ) under the ring name , Jay Lethal . Jamar Shipman ( born April 21 , 1985 in Elizabeth , New Jersey ) , better known by his ring name Jay Lethal , is an American professional wrestler , currently working for Total Nonstop Action Wrestling .