Notts County made up for this on 1894-03-31 , when they won the FA Cup at Goodison Park for the first and thus far only time in their history . The Magpies defeated Bolton Wanderers 4-1 in a game in which Jimmy Logan scored the first hat-trick in FA Cup final history . Notts County made up for this on 31 March 1894 , when they won the FA Cup at Goodison Park , defeating Bolton Wanderers 4-1 in a game in which Jimmy Logan scored the second hat-trick in FA Cup final history .