After efforts by the eliminated and nonparticipant contestants to come up with an impartial way of determining the winner all fail , Chris ( supposedly leaving on vacation ) ultimately returns to the set and has the eliminated ( but not the nonparticipant ) contestants vote for the winner who was eventually Duncan . After efforts by the eliminated and nonparticipant contestants to come up with an impartial way of determining the winner all fail , Chris ( supposedly leaving on vacation ) ultimately returns to the set and has the eliminated ( but not the nonparticipant ) contestants vote for the winner , who was eventually Duncan .