Meredith Monroe ( born December 30 , 1968 ) is an American actress She is best-known for her role as Andie McPhee on Dawson 's Creek from 1998 to 2000 . Meredith Leigh Monroe ( born December 30 , 1968 ) , is an American actress who portrayed Andie McPhee on Dawson 's Creek from 1998 to 2000 .