Despite its big commercial success , Siren Song of the Counter Culture is not Rise Against 's highest charting album on the Billboard 200 , peaking at number 136 ; subsequent albums The Sufferer & The Witness and Appeal to Reason both charted higher , peaking at number 10 and number 3 . While the album was commercially successful , Siren Song of the Counter Culture is not Rise Against 's highest charting album on the Billboard 200 , peaking only at # 136 ; subsequent albums The Sufferer & The Witness and Appeal to Reason both charted higher , peaking at # 10 and # 3 respectively .