Rupert Boneham returned in Survivor : All-Stars and made 4th place , then Jon `` Jonny Fairplay '' Dalton played again in Survivor : Micronesia , and was the first person voted out that season . Rupert Boneham returned to the Pearl Islands for Survivor : All-Stars , placing 4th . Jon `` Jonny Fairplay '' Dalton briefly participated in Survivor : Micronesia , before getting voted out in the first episode .