Below is an context that describes a sql query, paired with an question that provides further information. Write an answer that appropriately completes the request.  # noqa: E501
### Context:
CREATE TABLE table_18159601_1 (city VARCHAR, charter_date VARCHAR)
### Question:
in which city was charter date december 4, 2011
### Answer:
SELECT city FROM table_18159601_1 WHERE charter_date = "December 4, 2011"