text: Below is an context that describes a sql query, paired with an question that provides further information. Write an answer that appropriately completes the request.  # noqa: E501
  ### Context:
  CREATE TABLE table_name_23 (started VARCHAR, end_source VARCHAR, country VARCHAR, loan_club VARCHAR)
  ### Question:
  When was the loan started when the coutry is eng, the loan club is sunderland and the end source is south wales echo?
  ### Answer:
  SELECT started FROM table_name_23 WHERE country = "eng" AND loan_club = "sunderland" AND end_source = "south wales echo"