Highest vote pct.: 0.4%. His tiny vote total probably makes him the most underrated pitcher of all time. Virtually tied with Hall of Famer Jim Palmer, a Reuschel contemporary who pitched for much better clubs. Kenny Lofton. Adjusted WAR: 64.1. Highest vote pct.: 3.2% Journeyman during second half of his career, but his several big years in Cleveland before that almost seem forgotten. Kevin Brown. Adjusted WAR: 63.3. Highest vote pct.: 2.1%