Most / Least Educated Cities in FL. The average temperature of Carrabelle is 67.51°F, which is lower than the Florida average temperature of 71.80°F and is much higher than the national average temperature of 54.45°F.4.63 mph. U.S. 16.93 mph. * The temperature, snow fall, and precipitation information on this page were calculated from the historical data of 18,000+ U.S weather stations for the period of time from 1980 to 2010.