Best Answer: Yes, you would be able to move your toe, even if its broken. Of course it will hurt a bit. The bad thing is there is nothing you can do about a broken to except to buddy tape it with your other toe.What I mean by the is tape your broken toe to the to toe next to it.he bad thing is there is nothing you can do about a broken to except to buddy tape it with your other toe. What I mean by the is tape your broken toe to the to toe next to it.