We do not have the Payment Methods Accepted at this Pizza Shop. Most Business accept Cash and Major Credit Cards. Please contact Sal's Pizza at (920) 955-4444 to find out payment options & Other details. Nearby Pizza Shops. Here is a list of Pizza Shops close to Sal's Pizza. View all Pizza Shops in Appleton, or Pizza Shops in Zip code 54911. Map | Directions | sms 0.0 MILES Speakeasy Ultra Lounge. 425 W College Ave, Appleton, WI-54911 (920) 830-1361