1 Dental insurance might cover 15%-50% of wisdom tooth removal if the procedure is considered medically necessary, and some dental plans only pay an annual maximum of $1,000-$1,500. 2  CostHelper readers without insurance report total costs of $250-$750 for extracting a single impacted wisdom tooth. CostHelper readers without dental insurance reported paying $720-$2,735 to have all four wisdom teeth removed at once, for an average cost of $1,616.