Natalie Schafer was 90 years old when he/she died. Well, that is up to you to decide! Click the HOT-Button if you think that Natalie Schafer was hot, or click NOT if you don't think so. 83% of all voters think that Natalie Schafer was hot, 17% voted for Not Hot. Natalie Schafer died on the 10th of April 1991, which was a Wednesday.